Tools

Home > ARM vs Fixed Calculator

⇅

ARM vs Fixed Calculator

Two offers sat in front of Nina: a fixed rate she could count on for 30 years, and an adjustable rate that started lower for five years and then reset to something unknown. The adjustable offer's first five years looked cheaper, and the lender's brochure emphasised those years. Nina wanted to see the whole loan, including the years after the reset, before choosing. This calculator shows both. Enter the loan, the fixed rate, the adjustable starting rate, the reset year and a reset rate you choose, and it shows the initial payment, the balance at reset, and the payment after reset. The reset rate is your scenario, not a prediction — try a kind one and a harsh one.

$$

Calculator

Worked example

Nina's loan is $300,000. The fixed offer at 6.5% over 30 years costs $1,896.20 a month for the whole term. The adjustable offer starts at 5.5%, costing $1,703.37 a month for the first five years — a saving of $192.83 a month while it lasts. After 60 payments the balance is $277,381.81. If the rate then resets to 7.5% for the remaining 25 years, the payment jumps to $2,049.83 a month — $153.62 above the fixed payment, every month, for 25 years. The five cheap years save about $11,570 in payments, and the 25 expensive years cost about $46,089 extra against the fixed alternative. On this scenario the adjustable loan loses, and the loss is not close.

Run the kind scenario and the story changes, which is exactly the point. If the reset rate lands at 6.0% instead of 7.5%, the post-reset payment falls below the fixed payment and the adjustable loan wins overall. The adjustable choice is therefore a bet on future rates, and the calculator's job is to show the stakes of that bet rather than to make it. A borrower who will sell or refinance before the reset never faces the reset at all, and for them the cheap initial years are nearly free money. A borrower who will still be in the house at reset is gambling the family budget on a rate nobody can promise.

How adjustable loans actually reset

An adjustable-rate mortgage is defined by its structure, usually written as two numbers such as 5/1: five years fixed, then adjusting once a year. Caps limit how far the rate can move at each adjustment and over the life of the loan, and the new rate is typically an index plus a margin set in the loan documents. Those details matter enormously and this calculator simplifies them deliberately: it models a single reset to a rate you choose, which is enough to show the stakes but not a substitute for reading the adjustment terms. Ask the lender for the index, the margin, the caps and the adjustment frequency in writing, then test the worst case the caps allow — if the payment at the maximum capped rate would break your budget, the loan is too risky regardless of the initial rate.

Interest-only adjustable loans add a further trap. During an interest-only period the balance does not fall at all, so the reset payment is calculated on the full original balance, and the payment shock is larger. Some adjustable loans also allow negative amortisation, where the payment does not even cover the interest and the balance grows. Those features can make an initially cheap loan genuinely dangerous, and they are the reason adjustable loans deserve more scrutiny, not less, than fixed loans. If a loan document contains either feature and you do not fully understand it, do not sign until someone independent has explained it.

Who should even consider adjustable

Three borrowers can reasonably consider an adjustable loan. The first is the short-stay buyer who will sell or refinance before the first reset, for whom the initial saving is real and the reset irrelevant. The second is the borrower with large, reliable income growth expected before reset, who can absorb a higher payment later. The third is the sophisticated borrower who understands caps and indices and has priced the worst case. Everyone else — especially first-time buyers stretching to afford the initial payment, with no slack for a reset jump — is usually safer fixed. The fixed payment's virtue is not that it is cheap; it is that it is known, and a known payment can be planned around for thirty years.

Frequently asked questions

Is the reset rate a prediction?

No. It is a scenario you enter. Try a low, a central and a high reset rate and see how the answer changes — that range is the real risk.

What are rate caps?

Limits in the loan documents on how much the rate can rise at each adjustment and over the loan's life. Ask for them in writing and test the maximum.

Should I choose adjustable if I move in four years?

Possibly — if the reset is after five years, you may never face it. But a forced move is never certain, so keep a margin for staying longer.

Is fixed always safer?

Fixed is more predictable, not always cheaper. If rates fall, a fixed borrower pays the old rate unless they refinance, which has its own costs.

Related tools

Mortgage Calculator
Refinance Calculator
Loan EMI Calculator

Before you use this result

Test the maximum rate your loan's caps allow, not just the rate you hope for. If the payment at that maximum would strain your budget, choose the fixed loan — predictability is worth more than a cheap first five years.

Sources

Official pages you can check for the rules and terms used on this page. No rate on this page is copied from these sources — rates are entered by you or labelled as examples, because a copied rate goes out of date.

Disclaimer: This tool is for education only and is not financial, tax or investment advice. Figures are estimates based on the inputs you enter.