Tools

Home > Rent vs Buy Calculator

🏠

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Jonas and Priya rented a flat for $2,200 a month and argued about it every spring when the renewal letter arrived. Buying felt grown-up, renting felt flexible, and neither of them could tell which was cheaper over a decade because the answer depends on things nobody knows yet — how fast rents rise, how fast prices rise, and how long they stay. This calculator does not pretend to know those things. It takes your rent, your assumptions for rent growth and price growth, and a house you describe, then lays the ten-year costs side by side so you can see which assumption changes the answer.

$$

Calculator

Worked example

With rent at $2,200 a month growing 3% a year, ten years of renting costs $302,646.41 in total. Buying the $350,000 house with $70,000 down leaves a $280,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years, whose principal-and-interest payment is $1,769.79 a month; add $550 for tax, insurance and HOA and the monthly housing cost is $2,319.79, or $278,374.86 over ten years. After ten years the loan balance is $237,373.15, the house at 2% annual growth is worth $426,648.05, and the equity built is $189,274.89. On payments alone buying looks slightly cheaper here, and on equity it looks much better — but both conclusions rest on the growth assumptions, which is why the calculator shows its working instead of declaring a winner.

Change one assumption and watch the story flip. Set price growth to zero and the equity gain collapses to the principal repaid, about $42,627 over the decade. Set rent growth to 5% and renting becomes far more expensive. Set the stay to three years instead of ten and buying's upfront costs — closing, moving, selling fees, which this calculator does not include — dominate everything. The honest use of this tool is not to find the answer but to find the assumption your answer depends on, and then to judge how likely that assumption is.

The costs this comparison leaves out, on purpose

No ten-year comparison can include everything, so this one is explicit about its gaps. On the buying side it leaves out closing costs at purchase, maintenance and repairs, selling costs when you leave, and the opportunity cost of the down payment — money that could have been invested elsewhere. On the renting side it leaves out the freedom to move cheaply, which has real value if your job or family situation changes. Maintenance alone can run to thousands a year on an older house, and one bad roof can erase several years of apparent buying advantage. Treat the calculator's totals as the core housing costs, then add your own estimates for the rest before deciding.

Tax is another gap, deliberately. Mortgage interest and property tax may be deductible for some buyers and worthless to others, depending on whether they itemise and on current law, which changes. Rather than baking in a tax guess that would be wrong for half its readers, the calculator shows pre-tax costs and leaves the tax question to your own return or adviser. If deductibility matters to your decision, estimate it separately and add it to the buying side as a credit.

How long you stay is the real decision

Ask any housing economist what matters most and the answer is usually the horizon. Over two or three years, buying rarely wins: the fixed costs are spread over too few months, and price movements over such a short period are mostly noise. Over ten years or more, the balance shifts, because the mortgage payment stays roughly fixed while rents compound, and because principal repayment quietly builds equity even if prices stand still. The calculator's ten-year window is a reasonable middle ground, but if your own horizon is three years or twenty, re-run the mental version with that horizon in mind: shorter favours renting, longer favours buying, and the crossover point is different for every city and every price.

Frequently asked questions

Does buying always build wealth?

No. It builds equity through principal repayment, but price falls, high maintenance or a forced early sale can still leave a buyer worse off than a renter.

Why is rent growth an assumption, not a fact?

Because future rents are unknowable. The calculator uses your growth figure so you can test optimistic and pessimistic versions instead of trusting one hidden guess.

Are closing and selling costs included?

No. Add your own estimates for purchase closing costs, maintenance and eventual selling costs to the buying total before deciding.

What if I move in three years?

Then buying usually loses, because fixed costs are spread over few months. The ten-year comparison does not apply to a short stay.

Related tools

Mortgage Calculator
Home Affordability Calculator
Closing Costs Estimator

Before you use this result

Run the comparison three times: once with your central assumptions, once with price growth at zero, and once with rent growth two points higher. If the same side wins all three times, your decision is robust. If the winner changes, your decision is really a bet on that assumption — make it knowingly.

Sources

Official pages you can check for the rules and terms used on this page. No rate on this page is copied from these sources — rates are entered by you or labelled as examples, because a copied rate goes out of date.

Disclaimer: This tool is for education only and is not financial, tax or investment advice. Figures are estimates based on the inputs you enter.